{
  "schema": "adfactory.music-gap-adjudication/v1",
  "at": "2026-09-15T07:42:02.049261+00:00",
  "scope": "Model-mediated audition plus source text, matched measurements and author adjudication. No claim of human/native-Ukrainian hearing or independent performance data.",
  "validScopedReviews": [
    "micro-opening-v01",
    "micro-turn-v01",
    "micro-ending-v01",
    "backstory-v01",
    "auditory-facts-v01"
  ],
  "coverage": "11 overlapping A/B windows cover the full audio range of each track; coverage-v01.json. This is not one unbroken human whole-song listen.",
  "wholeAudioAttempt": {
    "id": "whole-audio-v01",
    "status": "provider-error-outcome-unresolved",
    "repeated": false
  },
  "wholeFormAttempt": {
    "id": "form-independent-v01",
    "status": "returned-unreliable-schema-failed",
    "repeated": false
  },
  "rejectedOrQualifiedClaims": [
    {
      "claim": "Targ has two seconds of empty rest after week six",
      "status": "rejected",
      "reason": "Targeted full-mix and separated-vocal audition identifies a held six, short breath, then I. Exact subsecond boundaries remain approximate.",
      "evidence": "reviews/auditory-facts-v01/evaluation.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Our selfworth section lost her/my contrast or has no climax",
      "status": "rejected",
      "reason": "Both sources emphasize contrastive pronouns. New intimate resolution is a strength and receives more semantic-block time.",
      "evidence": "reviews/auditory-facts-v01/evaluation.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Stop is complete zero-level silence",
      "status": "rejected",
      "reason": "Accented vocal/instrumental hit with decay and brief stop-time is different from zero audio.",
      "evidence": "reviews/auditory-facts-v01/evaluation.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Targ CTA is ordinary speech or dead air; both endings are unmusical",
      "status": "rejected",
      "reason": "Targeted review hears narrow rhythmic singing; source continues music/humming. Brand phonetics uncertain; no proved placeholder defect.",
      "evidence": "reviews/auditory-facts-v01/evaluation.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Our notes are simply fewer or vocal range narrower",
      "status": "unsupported",
      "reason": "Matched F0 central ranges approximately equal. Pitch distribution is not note count or verified vocal range.",
      "evidence": "measurements/summary-v01.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Exact minor key, 6/8, octave jumps, triplets, notated note values",
      "status": "not-established",
      "reason": "Unverified listening labels; automatic key candidates compete; no independent score/chord/meter transcription.",
      "evidence": "reviews/micro-opening-v01/evaluation.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Independent form review establishes whole-song comparative acceptance",
      "status": "rejected-as-gate",
      "reason": "mediaAccess/audioAccess are strings, not required booleans; fabricated words and source locators; UA CTA extends to3:31 outside197.726s. Raw retained; no accepted timing or lyric quote derived from it.",
      "evidence": "reviews/form-independent-v01/evaluation.json"
    },
    {
      "claim": "All local reviewer timestamps and heard words are exact",
      "status": "rejected",
      "reason": "Caption windows overlap; local reviewers sometimes mishear Ukrainian words. Fact-check ending locator also exceeds sent clip. Use bound file ranges and accepted text; speculative subsecond pointers are not ground truth.",
      "evidence": "reviews/auditory-facts-v01/evaluation.json"
    }
  ],
  "acceptedMainFindings": [
    "Both are real melodic songs; new warm delivery, instructions and selfworth ending are strengths.",
    "Source rhetorical repeat/variation and staged word revelation are sometimes compressed despite semantic coverage.",
    "New care and CTA expand while return scene contracts; source-relative dramatic allocation changes.",
    "Several composition-plan fields are generic across phrases; whole-reference input coverage was limited in prior whole-master review."
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Requested native3.8 model identity is recorded but provider response does not independently attest every served model.",
    "Model reviews may hallucinate; accepted conclusions combine auditable words, actual assets and targeted adjudication.",
    "No verified note-by-note score or harmonic transcription.",
    "No new owner rating, advertisement outcome measurement, generated media or production gate change."
  ]
}